Skip to main content

Plan ahead and receive feedback — at a discount — on your 2027 assessment.

Contact Us

Search

Blog

Does the Nonprofit Sector Actually Have a ‘Narrative Problem?’

Date: November 3, 2026
Phil Buchanan

Phil Buchanan

President, CEP

Never Miss A Post

Share this Post:

Date: November 3, 2026
Phil Buchanan

Phil Buchanan

President, CEP

In the last couple of years, I have heard a lot about the nonprofit sector’s “narrative problem.” Indeed, researchers and leaders have been convened by several of the largest foundations in the country to discuss what to do about it.

But I am a little dubious that nonprofits have as big of a narrative problem as some think they do.

One statistic frequently cited by those making the case that the sector has a problem relates to the purportedly low proportion of Americans who say their lives have been affected by nonprofits. People will say, with alarm, that “only 5%” or “only 7%” of Americans “even think that a nonprofit has affected their lives.”

I have heard this countless times in meetings and at conferences; maybe you have, too. This data point has taken on a life of its own, as data points sometimes do.

Here’s the thing: it’s not accurate.

A Distorted Data Point

The research that is the basis for that assertion comes from the Lilly School of Philanthropy at Indiana University. In a recently released research report, the authors write “just 7.4% of respondents indicated that they or someone in their immediate family had received or used services from a charitable organization in the past year. This was slightly higher than in the 2023 report, when 5.4% of respondents indicated the same.” (Italics are mine.)

This is quite different than the way it’s been shorthanded in two crucial ways.

The first is the time period — a year is a short time in an adult’s life. The researchers might illicit a very different response if they’d asked, for example, “in the past decade” or “in your lifetime.” To be fair, a year recall period is standard in survey research and a longer one could be problematic. So, my critique here is less with the timeframe than with the way it’s been mischaracterized by those whose citation of this data has been imprecise at best.

The second issue is more about the question itself — and the wording with respect to receiving or using services. I have great respect for the Lilly School, which puts out a lot of great research, but this strikes me as a poorly worded question if the goal is to measure interaction with nonprofits (or recognition of the value nonprofits add to their community).

The authors juxtapose the 7.4% saying they had “received or used services” to the much higher proportions saying they had, for example “attended religious services” (46.5%), “visited a museum” (35.5%), or “attended an event at a performing arts organization (e.g., theaters, dance companies, symphonies, etc.)” (29.7%), in the past year. On this basis, they conclude that there is “a substantial recognition gap: Americans may interact with nonprofits regularly while not identifying those interactions as nonprofit service use.”

One of the Lilly School staffers who worked on the report writes, in a piece on the Candid site last week, “In other words, among those using nonprofit programs, almost 90% don’t realize they’re doing so.”

I am not convinced. I think they were simply asked the wrong question.

Nonprofits Aren’t Just Providing ‘Services’

I mean, does someone who visited a museum or watched a play or a concert see themselves as having “received services?” I doubt it. The activities cited above are meaningful interactions with nonprofits and my guess is that they actually are seen as such by many Americans. But, to the average person, they wouldn’t go in the bucket of “receiving service.”

The same would be true for, say, walking on a trail maintained by a local nonprofit and countless other nonprofit-provided activities. I go on a walk in the woods, grateful that the area has been maintained by a nonprofit, but I certainly don’t see myself in that moment as “receiving a service.” I wonder if future efforts could ask a broader question about interactions with nonprofits that feels more inclusive of experiences like these?

I think it is more likely we have a semantic problem with a poorly worded survey question (and, look, I empathize, having regretted word choices on surveys we fielded more than a few times) than evidence that Americans in large numbers don’t recognize that nonprofits affect their lives. Indeed, I think the Lilly School’s own report belies the notion that Americans don’t see nonprofits’ good work because it shows higher levels of confidence to “solve societal or global problems” in nonprofits than in government and business. More than 70% profess high or moderate confidence in nonprofits, compared to just 42% saying the same about large corporations and fewer still about Congress.

Where would that confidence be developed if not in Americans’ interactions with nonprofits?

The Lilly School report’s authors portray the results of the public polling data they describe in a more negative light than I think is warranted, at one point conceding that “Americans may view nonprofits more favorably than many other institutions” but hastening to add that they are “still expressing only measured confidence in the sector’s ability to solve societal or global problems.”

But solving societal or global problems strikes me as a high bar indeed, and I would imagine the merely “measured” nature of the public’s confidence comes from the fact that such problems typically require multiple sectors, including government, to truly “solve.”

Moreover, many nonprofits play vital roles but don’t claim they are in the position to “solve” a “societal or global problem.” Most are local, after all, and may be doing something that simply makes life better or eases suffering for those in their community. We need those organizations  — and I think Americans know that.

Trust Levels Others Can Only Dream About

Indeed, a recent Independent Sector report conducted in partnership with Edelman Data & Intelligence shows high levels of trust in nonprofits. “This year’s findings show that nonprofits remain a rare point of common ground,” Independent Sector notes. “Americans continue to trust nonprofit organizations more than government institutions, corporations, the media, and philanthropy — and increasingly see nonprofits as institutions that can bring people together and improve their communities.”

What if we saw this as a platform of strength on which to build — because that is what it actually is? What if we celebrated the fact, and it is a fact, that nonprofits are trusted to a degree others — like large corporations and government — can only dream of? (It’s worth noting that charitable organizations are also more trusted than foundations.)

Look, I am all for doing more to communicate the value and importance of nonprofits, which I do believe are too often disparaged by some — especially Silicon Valley tech and crypto titans and those with power (including many in the current administration) who see them as a threat — even as they are trusted and valued by most of us. I have spent much energy over the course of my career trying to tell the story of American nonprofits working in every community, often staffed by people who I consider, as I put it in my 2019 book Giving Done Right, “unsung American heroes.”

I’d be the first to say we should not take anything for granted. We should absolutely focus on telling the story of nonprofits!

But I think misdiagnosing the current public perceptions of nonprofits may lead people to focus on the wrong action steps or even to underestimate the power of nonprofits, which goes far beyond the provision of “services” to “recipients” (although this can be crucially important).

The challenge, I suspect, is not to educate Americans about the fact that they interact with nonprofits all the time. It is, instead, to build on the foundation of trust with the public, created by those interactions, to help motivate more action: giving, volunteering, defending the diverse array of organizations doing crucial work in every community.

I don’t think there are easy answers when it comes to how to do that. But I know we’ll be more likely to figure out the right steps if we start on common ground about the state of public perceptions today.

Phil Buchanan is president of the Center for Effective Philanthropy, author of “Giving Done Right: Effective Philanthropy and Making Every Dollar Count,” and host of the Giving Done Right podcast which is currently in its 6th season. 


Note: If you’re interested in learning more about the research discussed in this post and hearing different takes on the implications of the data, I’ll be joining a webinar sponsored by the Lilly School November 9. I appreciate their invitation and openness to alternate perspectives. More information here.

Editor’s Note: CEP publishes a range of perspectives. The views expressed here are those of the authors, not necessarily those of CEP.

From the Blog

‘Make Support Easy To Say Yes To’: One Funder’s Approach to Capacity-Building SupportGeorgia Kazemi Analyst, Assessment and Advisory Services, CEPNick Arevalo Capacity Building Director, Tipping Point CommunityJacob Denney Research and Innovation Director, Tipping Point CommunityAli Sutton Chief Program Officer, Tipping Point Community
‘Make Support Easy To Say Yes To’: One Funder’s Approach to Capacity-Building Support

When I talk with funders about support beyond the grant, I often hear the same hesitation: How do we know it’s actually leading to impact? Do we have the capacity and staff time to provide this support? How should we structure it? Answers to these questions are...

read more